I don't really have oily lids, but this doesn't seem to stick to my eyelids like the Lakme eyeconic. It does smudge the tiniest bit when compared to the other 2.
It is water proof like the other two, but is definitely easier to remove compared to the lakme eyeconic, which seems to cling on to my eyelids for dear life! Maybelline Colossal for me isn't very easy to remove, because I think I over apply it.
It's a nice kajal that won't seem stark and harsh even though it's black. it's softer looking than the Lakme eyeconic (which still remains my favourite).
It did not sting or trouble my sensitive eyes at all. Definitely worth a tenure on your vanity! If the blackest black and super soft texture is your thing though (and a little extra seconds spent removing it), you can give it a miss!
Price Rs 245
Maybelline Colossal- Rs 175
Lakme Eyeconic - Rs 199
Ps: Press Sample